Simulposted with Voice of the Voiceless
by Peter Young
Jan 16th, 2010, Today I was sent a copy of judge Benson’s ruling in the ongoing case of Animal Liberation Front prisoner William “BJ” Viehl, charged with liberating 650 mink from a fur farm in Utah. In it, the judge lays out his argument for denying Viehl’s motion accusing the prosecution of violating the terms of his plea deal.
According to the plea deal, Viehl was to expect a sentence of six months. At sentencing, the judge threw out the plea bargain, and stated his intent to as much as quadruple Viehl’s sentence to two or more years.
In the opinion, Benson restates many arguments he made at BJ’s first sentencing, in favor of a sentence far outside the sentencing guidelines. These arguments include:
*BJ was “hailed as a hero on numerous websites.” This highlights something my own experiences echo: Those in the “justice system” become indignant at public support for those those who work to right wrongs outside the law.
*Viehl and codefendant Alex Hall allegedly being stopped near other mink farms in the region, at times when no crimes had occurred.
*Spray-painted messages left at the fur farm the night of the liberation reading “ALF,” “no more mink, no more murder,” and “We are watching”, the last of which the prosecution asserted proves the mink release “….is not just a property crime, it is a threat”.
*The testimony of mink farmer Lindsey McMullin, which the judge cited in BJ’s last court date as being the prime influence in his decision to hand down a sentence of two or more years. McMullin’s testimony was described by the judge as conveying… “the impact of the crime on his family, including the emotional impact on his young children, and the financial impact on his family business.”
The judge’s contempt for animal rights activists and the A.L.F. comes through in this document. Read the full text here: William Viehl Sentencing Decision
-Peter Young
Peter Young is NIO’s Senior Editor of Animal Liberation and the creator of VoiceOfTheVoiceless.org. Young is a veteran animal liberation activist and former political prisoner convicted for his role in liberating thousands of animals from fur farms across the country. Emerging from a grand jury indictment, 7 years of being wanted by the FBI, a federal prison sentence, and nearly 15 years in the animal liberation movement; today Peter is a frequent lecturer at universities and events, writer on liberation movements, and unapologetic supporter of those who work outside the law to achieve human, earth, and animal liberation.
If the nonhumans could fight back, their tormentors would have expired long ago. We have an obligation to expose the abusers. It is the LEAST we can do! I welcome your emails & contributions.
If you have a Facebook account, join the extended Negotiation Is Over network.”.
To submit work to NIO for consideration and publication, please send an email to camille@negotationisover.com with the subject “submission”.
To receive NIO updates, please send an email to camille@negotiationisover.com with the subject “subscriptions”.
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!